# ADR Implementation Tracker This document tracks the implementation status and estimated effort for all Architectural Decision Records (ADRs). ## Effort Estimation Guide | Rating | Description | Typical Duration | | ------ | ------------------------------------------- | ----------------- | | S | Small - Simple, isolated changes | 1-2 hours | | M | Medium - Multiple files, some testing | Half day to 1 day | | L | Large - Significant refactoring, many files | 1-3 days | | XL | Extra Large - Major architectural change | 1+ weeks | ## Implementation Status Overview | Status | Count | | ---------------------------- | ----- | | Accepted (Fully Implemented) | 42 | | Partially Implemented | 2 | | Proposed (Not Started) | 12 | | Superseded | 1 | --- ## Detailed Implementation Status ### Category 1: Foundational / Core Infrastructure | ADR | Title | Status | Effort | Notes | | ---------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------- | -------- | ------ | ------------------------------ | | [ADR-002](./0002-standardized-transaction-management.md) | Transaction Management | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-007](./0007-configuration-and-secrets-management.md) | Configuration & Secrets | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-020](./0020-health-checks-and-liveness-readiness-probes.md) | Health Checks | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-030](./0030-graceful-degradation-and-circuit-breaker.md) | Circuit Breaker | Proposed | L | New resilience patterns needed | ### Category 2: Data Management | ADR | Title | Status | Effort | Notes | | --------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------ | ---------- | ------ | ------------------------------ | | [ADR-009](./0009-caching-strategy-for-read-heavy-operations.md) | Caching Strategy | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-013](./0013-database-schema-migration-strategy.md) | Schema Migrations v1 | Superseded | - | Superseded by ADR-023 | | [ADR-019](./0019-data-backup-and-recovery-strategy.md) | Backup & Recovery | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-023](./0023-database-schema-migration-strategy.md) | Schema Migrations v2 | Proposed | L | Requires tooling setup | | [ADR-031](./0031-data-retention-and-privacy-compliance.md) | Data Retention & Privacy | Proposed | XL | Legal/compliance review needed | ### Category 3: API & Integration | ADR | Title | Status | Effort | Notes | | ------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------ | -------- | ------ | ------------------------------------- | | [ADR-003](./0003-standardized-input-validation-using-middleware.md) | Input Validation | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-008](./0008-api-versioning-strategy.md) | API Versioning | Accepted | - | Phase 2 complete, tests migrated | | [ADR-018](./0018-api-documentation-strategy.md) | API Documentation | Accepted | - | OpenAPI/Swagger implemented | | [ADR-022](./0022-real-time-notification-system.md) | Real-time Notifications | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-028](./0028-api-response-standardization.md) | Response Standardization | Accepted | - | Completed (routes, middleware, tests) | ### Category 4: Security & Compliance | ADR | Title | Status | Effort | Notes | | ----------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------- | -------- | ------ | -------------------------------- | | [ADR-001](./0001-standardized-error-handling.md) | Error Handling | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-011](./0011-advanced-authorization-and-access-control-strategy.md) | Authorization & RBAC | Proposed | XL | Policy engine, permission system | | [ADR-016](./0016-api-security-hardening.md) | Security Hardening | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-029](./0029-secret-rotation-and-key-management.md) | Secret Rotation | Proposed | L | Infrastructure changes needed | | [ADR-032](./0032-rate-limiting-strategy.md) | Rate Limiting | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-033](./0033-file-upload-and-storage-strategy.md) | File Upload & Storage | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-048](./0048-authentication-strategy.md) | Authentication | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | ### Category 5: Observability & Monitoring | ADR | Title | Status | Effort | Notes | | --------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------------- | -------- | ------ | ------------------------------------------ | | [ADR-004](./0004-standardized-application-wide-structured-logging.md) | Structured Logging | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-015](./0015-error-tracking-and-observability.md) | Error Tracking | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-050](./0050-postgresql-function-observability.md) | PostgreSQL Fn Observability | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-051](./0051-asynchronous-context-propagation.md) | Context Propagation | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-052](./0052-granular-debug-logging-strategy.md) | Granular Debug Logging | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-056](./0056-application-performance-monitoring.md) | APM (Performance) | Proposed | M | tracesSampleRate=0, intentionally disabled | ### Category 6: Deployment & Operations | ADR | Title | Status | Effort | Notes | | -------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------ | -------- | ------ | ------------------------ | | [ADR-006](./0006-background-job-processing-and-task-queues.md) | Background Jobs | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-014](./0014-containerization-and-deployment-strategy.md) | Containerization | Partial | M | Docker done, K8s pending | | [ADR-017](./0017-ci-cd-and-branching-strategy.md) | CI/CD & Branching | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-024](./0024-feature-flagging-strategy.md) | Feature Flags | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-037](./0037-scheduled-jobs-and-cron-pattern.md) | Scheduled Jobs | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-038](./0038-graceful-shutdown-pattern.md) | Graceful Shutdown | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-053](./0053-worker-health-checks.md) | Worker Health | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-054](./0054-bugsink-gitea-issue-sync.md) | Bugsink-Gitea Sync | Proposed | L | Automated issue creation | ### Category 7: Frontend / User Interface | ADR | Title | Status | Effort | Notes | | ------------------------------------------------------------------------ | -------------------- | -------- | ------ | ------------------------------------------- | | [ADR-005](./0005-frontend-state-management-and-server-cache-strategy.md) | State Management | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-012](./0012-frontend-component-library-and-design-system.md) | Component Library | Partial | L | Core components done, design tokens pending | | [ADR-025](./0025-internationalization-and-localization-strategy.md) | i18n & l10n | Proposed | XL | All UI strings need extraction | | [ADR-026](./0026-standardized-client-side-structured-logging.md) | Client-Side Logging | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-044](./0044-frontend-feature-organization.md) | Feature Organization | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | ### Category 8: Development Workflow & Quality | ADR | Title | Status | Effort | Notes | | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------------------- | -------- | ------ | -------------------- | | [ADR-010](./0010-testing-strategy-and-standards.md) | Testing Strategy | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-021](./0021-code-formatting-and-linting-unification.md) | Formatting & Linting | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-027](./0027-standardized-naming-convention-for-ai-and-database-types.md) | Naming Conventions | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-040](./0040-testing-economics-and-priorities.md) | Testing Economics | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-045](./0045-test-data-factories-and-fixtures.md) | Test Data Factories | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-047](./0047-project-file-and-folder-organization.md) | Project Organization | Proposed | XL | Major reorganization | | [ADR-057](./0057-test-remediation-post-api-versioning.md) | Test Remediation | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | ### Category 9: Architecture Patterns | ADR | Title | Status | Effort | Notes | | --------------------------------------------------------------------- | --------------------- | -------- | ------ | ------------------------- | | [ADR-034](./0034-repository-pattern-standards.md) | Repository Pattern | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-035](./0035-service-layer-architecture.md) | Service Layer | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-036](./0036-event-bus-and-pub-sub-pattern.md) | Event Bus | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-039](./0039-dependency-injection-pattern.md) | Dependency Injection | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-041](./0041-ai-gemini-integration-architecture.md) | AI/Gemini Integration | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-042](./0042-email-and-notification-architecture.md) | Email & Notifications | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-043](./0043-express-middleware-pipeline.md) | Middleware Pipeline | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-046](./0046-image-processing-pipeline.md) | Image Processing | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-049](./0049-gamification-and-achievement-system.md) | Gamification System | Accepted | - | Fully implemented | | [ADR-055](./0055-database-normalization-and-referential-integrity.md) | DB Normalization | Accepted | M | API uses IDs, not strings | --- ## Work Still To Be Completed (Priority Order) These ADRs are proposed or partially implemented, ordered by suggested implementation priority: | Priority | ADR | Title | Status | Effort | Rationale | | -------- | ------- | ------------------------ | -------- | ------ | ------------------------------------ | | 1 | ADR-054 | Bugsink-Gitea Sync | Proposed | L | Automated issue tracking from errors | | 2 | ADR-023 | Schema Migrations v2 | Proposed | L | Database evolution support | | 3 | ADR-029 | Secret Rotation | Proposed | L | Security improvement | | 4 | ADR-030 | Circuit Breaker | Proposed | L | Resilience improvement | | 5 | ADR-056 | APM (Performance) | Proposed | M | Enable when performance issues arise | | 6 | ADR-011 | Authorization & RBAC | Proposed | XL | Advanced permission system | | 7 | ADR-025 | i18n & l10n | Proposed | XL | Multi-language support | | 8 | ADR-031 | Data Retention & Privacy | Proposed | XL | Compliance requirements | --- ## Recent Implementation History | Date | ADR | Change | | ---------- | ------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | | 2026-01-28 | ADR-024 | Fully implemented - Backend/frontend feature flags, 89 tests, admin endpoint | | 2026-01-28 | ADR-057 | Created - Test remediation documentation for ADR-008 Phase 2 migration | | 2026-01-28 | ADR-013 | Marked as Superseded by ADR-023 | | 2026-01-27 | ADR-008 | Test path migration complete - 23 files, ~70 paths updated, 274->345 tests passing | | 2026-01-27 | ADR-008 | Phase 2 Complete - Version router factory, deprecation headers, 82 versioning tests | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-015 | Completed - Added Sentry user context in AuthProvider, now fully implemented | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-056 | Created - APM split from ADR-015, status Proposed (tracesSampleRate=0) | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-015 | Refactored to focus on error tracking only, temporarily status Partial | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-048 | Verified as fully implemented - JWT + OAuth authentication complete | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-022 | Verified as fully implemented - WebSocket notifications complete | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-052 | Marked as fully implemented - createScopedLogger complete | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-053 | Marked as fully implemented - /health/queues endpoint complete | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-050 | Marked as fully implemented - PostgreSQL function observability | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-055 | Created (renumbered from duplicate ADR-023) - DB normalization | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-054 | Added to tracker - Bugsink to Gitea issue synchronization | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-053 | Added to tracker - Worker health checks and monitoring | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-052 | Added to tracker - Granular debug logging strategy | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-051 | Added to tracker - Asynchronous context propagation | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-048 | Added to tracker - Authentication strategy | | 2026-01-26 | ADR-040 | Added to tracker - Testing economics and priorities | | 2026-01-17 | ADR-054 | Created - Bugsink-Gitea sync worker proposal | | 2026-01-11 | ADR-050 | Created - PostgreSQL function observability with fn_log() | | 2026-01-11 | ADR-018 | Implemented - OpenAPI/Swagger documentation at /docs/api-docs | | 2026-01-11 | ADR-049 | Created - Gamification system, achievements, and testing | | 2026-01-09 | ADR-047 | Created - Project file/folder organization with migration plan | | 2026-01-09 | ADR-041 | Created - AI/Gemini integration with model fallback | | 2026-01-09 | ADR-042 | Created - Email and notification architecture with BullMQ | | 2026-01-09 | ADR-043 | Created - Express middleware pipeline ordering and patterns | | 2026-01-09 | ADR-044 | Created - Frontend feature-based folder organization | | 2026-01-09 | ADR-045 | Created - Test data factory pattern for mock generation | | 2026-01-09 | ADR-046 | Created - Image processing pipeline with Sharp and EXIF stripping | | 2026-01-09 | ADR-026 | Fully implemented - client-side structured logger | | 2026-01-09 | ADR-028 | Fully implemented - all routes, middleware, and tests updated | --- ## Notes - **Effort estimates** are rough guidelines and may vary based on current codebase state - **Dependencies** between ADRs should be considered when planning implementation order - This document should be updated when ADRs are implemented or status changes